New Site Comments 2.0 - is good but I have a but

Last Update: October 08, 2018

I have used Site Comments 2.0 quite a few times, attaining my 24 hours priority in the comments reply component, and receiving comments very quickly.

Which is a fantastic result.

However, during my third go at commenting for others I was asked to comment on female items, not rude or offensive at all, but I didn't think I was able to offer a comment which was suitable.

So I decided to "Skip" this one, upon which I received a message to the effect that if I continued with the "Skip" process I would lose 2 hours from my comment boost status.

I didn't want to lose 2 hours, period.

So I left a comment as best I could, I only hope that the website owner accepts my comment and approves it. Obviously if she doesn't it will have a negative impact on my stats.

I am not overly concerned about that negative impact, but I hate losing 2 hours from my comment boost status!


I wasn't going to write a post about this because I assumed it wouldn't happen too often and therefore it would not be an issue.

I completed my next comment and lo and behold the next post I get asked to comment on is from the same website, a different post but the same product (nearly).


Please note that I blacked out anything which would lead to the identification of the website owner or product, just as a courtesy, there is absolutely nothing wrong with the site itself.

I just want to mention that I don't believe it is fair that we lose time in this way when it is clear that it is uncomfortable for us to comment.

I guess it is better than commenting on the other rubbish we used to get, you know, something about increasing the size of things.

Join the Discussion
Write something…
Recent messages
Calvinator63 Premium
Hi Stephen,

As with all great improvements there are some occasional draw backs.

Maybe it might be a wise idea to address this issue to Carson so that possibly they could add a "Requested Comment not Related to my Interests" button so it will not count as a skip.

By offering feedback to the improvements it could allow them to address this issue and improve site comment even more so.

Just a thought,

Calvin
Reply
SteveCrozza Premium
Hi Calvin,
A good idea to do this, I just didn't think that it was such a big deal as there is an easy way around it.

ie Close the session and go back in later, which I know could be a nuisance.

I'll have a think about it.

Steve
Reply
Calvinator63 Premium
Hi Steve,

Yes a work a round is a temporary solution to the problem, but why not offer a more permanent solution that may make the next persons experience with site comment that much enjoyable or better.

Something to think about,

Calvin
Reply
TDenise Premium
I've had websites pop up that aren't entirely relevant to me as well. I do my best to comment on everyone's websites, but when they come back to back on topics that aren't relevant, it is hard. I do as you do and shut down my session. There's always pros and cons to everything. I still love the new Sitecomments platform!
Reply
SteveCrozza Premium
The platform is absolutely fantastic, the best thing that has been done since the last best thing!

Yeah, closing down works, and re-entering 5 minutes later is the key.
Reply
TDenise Premium
That's funny that you have an exact metric (5 minutes). Haha. I'll have to try that out. Thanks!
Reply
SteveCrozza Premium
It might be an exact metric in text but in reality 5 minutes could be half an hour. lol.
Reply
sukumarth Premium
I have edited my "interests" and have kept only two at the moment. Still, I get posts that have nothing to do with my chosen interests. I have to keep on skipping until I hit the wall where I'm told I have no more sites to offer comments then!
Reply
SteveCrozza Premium
That happened to me too.

I guess that closing down the session could be your answer, and try again later.

Teething problems I hope.
Reply
DBlanchard Premium
I think the problem right now is that there aren't enough members asking for comments and too many people giving some.

I stopped going to Site comment completely for a while because of the same reason you mention here. I have selected only one category in my interest but was still getting all kinds of subjects I had no interest or idea what to say about them...

Since the upgrade, Site Comment has exploded. I wrote a post about it 2 days ago ---> Just give it a break for a while, it should settle back to normal. But again that's my opinion.

If you want some direct answers, you should address your concerns directly to Carson... 😃

Denis
Reply
SteveCrozza Premium
I don't think there is any need to contact Carson because there will always be teething issues, and problems which we have to work around.

I think closing down the session and going back in 5 minutes later is the go.

I did see you post, good read.
Reply
Beverly-S Premium
I think Carson/Kyle would love to know. They tend to aim to please here. For the sake of a better/smoother experience for all, it may best, they know. Until then, I will use yr tip, Steve. Thanks 😊
Reply
SteveCrozza Premium
I have sent a message to Carson
Reply
CravenATAT Premium
I love the ability of being able to skip sites that don’t relate to me. Irony in this is that the exact site you listed is what I skipped, as it doesn’t related tot me at all. The only difficulty is that I had to skip two articles from that site as the owner requested comments on several pages!
Reply
SteveCrozza Premium
I got the same problem, two posts, I closed down my session so I didn't have to skip. lol
Reply
SteveCrozza Premium
Did you have shopping and products ticked?
Reply
CravenATAT Premium
Yes and I believe that is why
Reply
Top