Google Just Took Its Toys and Locked the Playground

byMrDon1

1.2K followers

3 months ago

Dale, I have to thank you for your post. It holds the pieces that opened my eyes to the problem, and I followed this down the rabbit hole to get a better understanding of the ground that we are standing on. The WHY.

Knowledge is Power... Is Dead?

I had a great post on this. I rolled out the stats that Google is losing all of its search revenue to the GPTs. Why sift through hundreds of links when ChatGPT can answer it quicker than you can find a valid link that may be incomplete?

I missed this. Google said, "Not so fast! You can't have our data to train your new toys.

Around January 15, 2025, Google quietly rolled out a major update. There was no news release, no fanfare, just a quiet rollout. But it blocked the traditional scraping of search results by tools like Jaaxy, SEMrush, and others. They stopped working properly. The scraped result only listed 10 ranking results instead of 100.

As a content blogger focused on our own niches, these technicalities did not register. Just another workaround.

Google Built a Fence

Google quietly rolled out anti-scraping measures that make it significantly harder to extract data from its Search Engine Results Pages (SERPs). These changes include:

• Mandatory JavaScript rendering: Search results now require JavaScript to load, which breaks traditional HTML scrapers.
• Rate limiting and IP throttling: Automated tools are being blocked or slowed down based on traffic patterns.
• CAPTCHA enforcement: Bots are being challenged more frequently, disrupting automated access.
• Advanced bot detection: Behavioral analysis and user-agent tracking are being used to flag suspicious activity.

Google silently told the world, "It is our data, and you cannot use it!"

No announcement. No warning. Just broken dashboards and vague explanations.

Why Google Did This?

AI models like ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity were eating Google's lunch for free! Imagine having free access to all of your competitors' data. What would you do with it? Use it against them? GPTs were doing just that. Using Google’s search results to train and generate answers.

Google saw the result. It was destroying its search business—people were asking GPTs to "Answer This" instead of "Googling It!" Thirty percent of their search business and billions in revenue is some serious cash.

To protect its ad revenue and data dominance, Google built a digital firewall around its search engine results. They took a page out of the Apple Playbook.

• Gemini Nano lives on Pixel devices
• Gemini Pro powers Bard and Workspace
• Gemini Ultra will be gated behind trust and security layers

This isn’t open AI at all. It is a Google stack-locked vault of intelligence.

If you want the best experience, you have to stay inside our environment—Gemini, Google Labs, Studio, etc.

The Real WHY is "To Starve the GPTs"

All of this is about cutting off the oxygen to external AI models that have been quietly feeding on Google’s SERPs for years.

Why? Because GPTs (and other LLMs) are:

• Answering questions directly, bypassing search
• Reducing ad impressions, threatening revenue
• Training on scraped data, eroding Google’s proprietary edge

Google’s Message is Clear

“Use our tools, stay in our ecosystem, and you’ll get the best AI experience. Step outside, and the data dries up.”

Ramifications for GPTs On the Outside Looking in

Claude (Anthropic)

Challenge: Claude doesn’t have a search engine or massive proprietary data stack. It relies on curated datasets and partnerships to get its data to train.

Recent Trouble: Hundreds of Claude conversations were indexed by Google despite Anthropic’s attempt to block the crawlers. This exposed user prompts and internal tasks—raising privacy concerns and showing how vulnerable Claude is to platform-level shifts.

Fightback Strategy:

• • Tighten data governance and sharing protocols.
  • Lean into partnerships with publishers or platforms that offer clean, licensed data.
  • Position Claude as a “safer” alternative to ChatGPT—less scraping, more ethics.

Perplexity

Challenge: Perplexity is built on real-time web search and summarization. It thrives on scraping and indexing.

Current Crisis: Accused of bypassing robots.txt and scraping sites that explicitly blocked it. Cloudflare claims millions of stealthy crawler requests per day.

• Fightback Strategy:
• • Either go rogue (continue scraping and risk legal/ethical backlash) or pivot to:
  • • Licensed content partnerships
    • User-contributed data
    • Decentralized search alliances (Web3-style)
      

Perplexity’s model is the most exposed. If Google’s SERPs become inaccessible, their core product loses its edge.

What is a Niche Blogger To Do?

If this is happening to AI, what are we to do? The tools we relied on, Jaaxy, SEMRush, Ahrefs, and Moz, are broken. Wealthy Affiliate offered updates, but the real issue was deeper than we needed a new solution. Keyword research became unreliable or expensive.

As Dale so eloquently pointed out, Search visibility dropped. Even if your content ranks, it may be buried under AI summaries or zero-click answers. For many of us, our Impressions declined. If you relied on Google to drive discovery, your numbers fell off the cliff, again!

You didn’t lose your ranking—you lost your position in the user’s journey. In the shift, you fell off the map.

What This Means Going Forward

The old model—write content, rank on Google, get traffic—is fading. If you were a one-trick pony, relying on Google search results, that river is drying up. Do you want to succeed? Google is telling you that to succeed, you have to use our tools. They are counting on you to succumb to their vast empire.

You will use our tools (Gemini, Studio, Labs, Search Console) or risk being invisible. They are counting on you paying more for access to their data. Will you?

If you don’t control your own data and audience, you’re building on rented land.

The New Way Forward

We know that Google is trying to herd all of us into their pens. Will you go willingly? What will survival and success look like in this New Google landscape? A monopolistic empire with one way in and no way out? Fight the rebellion with Microsoft and Copilot? Go Rogue and Create your own way forward?

Regardless of the path you consider, you must own your audience. Don’t depend on Google to deliver traffic. Build email lists, foster communities, and create rituals that bring people back to your content intentionally.

Whether it’s a weekly roundup, a newsletter, or a private group, direct engagement is now your most reliable channel.

Data Collector

Second, use first-party data. Pay attention to what your readers actually do. What they click, read, share, and respond to. This insight is gold, and it’s yours to keep. Let it guide your content strategy instead of relying on keyword tools that may no longer reflect reality.

What Do You Know?

Third, and foremost, create emotionally resonant content. This has been said in many different ways. AI killed the "How To" Blogger, the "Listicle Leader", and anyone living outside of "You Do You". You need to create content that resonates with your readers.

Even in so-called “dry” niches, there’s always a human angle.

AI and search algorithms increasingly favor content that feels useful, trustworthy, and engaging. If your posts connect with real people, they’ll rise above the noise even if they don’t rank #1.

Put Yourself Out There

Finally, diversify your stack. Don’t build your entire business inside Google’s ecosystem. Explore tools and platforms that support decentralized publishing, ethical data use, and AI-native analytics. The more control you have over your tech and your data, the less vulnerable you are to platform shifts.

This is a blueprint for sovereignty. The creators who embrace it won’t just survive the shift. They’ll lead it.

The Fence Is Up. The Gate Is Closed. Now What?

Google made its move. It very well could be an all-or-nothing move for them.

If you want access, you’ll pay for it or stay outside their stack. Will you play their game?

Creators like us were never meant to be fenced in. We built our brands on grit, insight, and connection.

We blog about what motivates us. Underserved niches, where we can illuminate the path for others, and in exchange, make a dollar or two. We do not live on rented algorithms.

So let them guard their toys. We’ll build new ones. Smarter. Sovereign. Mythic. The shift isn’t the end—it’s the invitation.

Let’s answer it.