Sticks and stones-really?

12
21
1.2K followers


According to Wikipedia:

Quote "Sticks and Stones" is an English language children's rhyme. It persuades the child victim of name-calling to ignore the taunt, to refrain from physical retaliation, and to remain calm and good-natured. Unquote

I thought I would share with you my own insights on this seemingly innocuous nursery rhyme which has become so entrenched in our highly flawed "received wisdom"

With my background in Education and EQ (Emotional Intelligence) I often wondered about the supposed "truth" enshrined in these words. Countless encounters with students and some adults always seemed to point to the opposite. In point of fact, many were highly intelligent and physically healthy but suffered considerably from poor self images and were hampered in their academic progress by limiting beliefs! A kind of emotional ill health seemed to pervade their thinking and ensued in general low morale and low esteem, which created a situation in which they became their own worst enemy.

Many regarded themselves as failures and felt rejected by their peers. They often became emotionally or socially disconnected and my heart reached out to them in their self made, lonely prisons. As a direct consequence they often functioned below their actual potential. I wondered what had caused them to become like this and realized that apart from their own poor self judgement in the face of personal situations and experiences of apparent failure, often people in positions of authority like over critical parents were responsible for reinforcing the damage. Some teachers for example...repeated the old self-fulfilling prophecy .......you will never be any good at Math.....and so on!

As a result It proved difficult for these students to change their thinking and it took a lot of effort for them to admit that the harsh words of so-called "authority" figures caused deep and lasting emotional wounds!

In more recent times advances in research in the fields of EQ and Psychology have begun to show just how much emotional ill health has been brought about by the injudicious use of words!

I believe that Dr Guy Winch, (not a real doctor lol) deals with this issue in a most inspiring way and after watching his TED talk, I am now more than ever optimistic that we will be embarking on a new era of enlightenment! He has a powerful message for us all!

"Can you imagine what the world would be like if everyone was psychologically healthier"

I know all fellow WA members will benefit from his talk! This is motivational stuff on steroids!

http://goo.gl/OQNsaZ

~Arthur


12
21

Join FREE & Launch Your Business!

Exclusive Bonus - Offer Ends at Midnight Today

00

Hours

:

00

Minutes

:

00

Seconds

2,000 AI Credits Worth $10 USD

Build a Logo + Website That Attracts Customers

400 Credits

Discover Hot Niches with AI Market Research

100 Credits

Create SEO Content That Ranks & Converts

800 Credits

Find Affiliate Offers Up to $500/Sale

10 Credits

Access a Community of 2.9M+ Members

By continuing, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
No credit card required

Recent Comments

21

Excellent Arthur. This part here:
" A kind of emotional ill health seemed to pervade their thinking and ensued in general low morale and low esteem, which created a situation in which they became their own worst enemy."

I have personal experience with this exact issue. It took many years for me to understand how this grows and often in a stealth manner due to a variety of things. The most difficult part I had in overcoming these things was to actually bring it to the surface and deal with the ugliness. I began to see how i turned into my own worst enemy. I didn't treat others badly, that's just not me, but I treated myself badly, due to how life unfolded over time.

Bottom line was that for me at least, once I brought it all to the surface and determined to take steps to undo the damage, I began to deal with my regrets, failures, etc., in a manner that required me to forgive myself and to commit to changing the way I thought about my own achievements, or lack thereof.

It can be very eye opening when we are willing to zoom in on our own self defeating thoughts and words we speak. I learned a great big step in dealing with these issues was to be HONEST with ourselves and stop denying what we already know is going on inside of us, if that makes sense.

I think we forget too often just how powerful words can be, and if we are going to change or alter our thinking, we must understand this fact and that includes the words we say to ourselves that can either drag us down or build us up. Indeed, there is much ill health when it comes to psychological matters, many of the problems come from the things said by others and what we begin to tell ourselves over time.

it can be self defeating for sure. Good stuff my friend, sorry for such a long response, but I did it as encouragement to others to know we can overcome these issues once we address them in honesty and refuse to let ego and pride blind us.

Have a great day
Jim

1

As a child, I would read some of the nursery rhymes and began you analyze the content and thought they were disgusting. Familial betrayal, wicked step parents, child abuse, neglect- I could go on. It is a very horrible message to send to our children.

2

Welcome to the world of the Brothers Grimm and company...I suppose their tales reflected the harshness of their times ...a kind of 'zeitgeist' not that that makes it OK by present day standards...

Thank goodness Walt Disney turned a lot of the original stories into ones carrying positive messages and the ultimate triumph of Good over Evil!

Thanks for your insight Debbie!
Kind regards
~Arthur

2

I love Disney!

2

Glad to hear you do Debbie, so do I! :-)

Having admitted that, I do think it important to point out that not all fairy tales or nursery rhymes are bad...there is in fact a whole lot of literature on the subject and I go with G.K. Chesterton who said:

“Fairy-tales are more than true, not because they tell us that dragons exist, but because they tell us that dragons can be beaten.” ―

1

It took me quite a few years to heal from the damage that had been done through verbal abuse in the home I was raised. I was always diligent to watch my words with my own children and I taught them from the time they were very little how important their words were. "Death and life are in the power of the tongue" Proverb 18:21 I think the worst part of verbal abuse is that without the visible physical scars very often people are not even aware of the damage that has been done. Thank you for sharing this wonderful video.

2

Thank you Christa,

Sorry to hear about your subjection to verbal abuse in your own family. Over the years, I realised that quite a lot of this was happening in some of my pupils!
The quote from the book of Proverbs is particularly apt and fitting! Few people realise the enormous damage that continued verbal abuse causes, especially as it is usually below the surface!

~Arthur

2

Yes it is true! I have a friend who once said to me, "well he never hit me." She was referring to her husband she had left. I told her, he hit you every time he verbally assaulted you it just didn't leave any visible bruise. She is now finally healing from his 35 years of verbal abuse.

2

Exactly what the good (not real..lol) doctor is asking.....why do we place so much emphasis on physical health and virtually none at all on psychological health?
Verbal abuse is no different to physical abuse!

2

Exactly and in many ways it is worse! I have experienced both and at least for me the physical was easier to heal from and more quickly healed from then the verbal.

2

TED always has good videos. Aside from being nice looking, this guy made a lot of good points. Women generally have horrible self talk.

2

Thanks Debbi,
You have put your finger on the nub of the issue......self talk....!
This is probably why so many of us are tuned in to motivational speakers and the like, some not so helpful!
~Arthur

2

I teach school too. I am seeing more and more like you said the students in their self-made prisons. I am teaching my students to walk around others and to not expect someone to move for them. This is the way things are now.
That is why I like to put on the clown makeup and make someone's day brighter. I have heard that even in wartorn countries that clowns bring a new light into the people's existence.
You are welcome to visit my clown world at http://beaclown.siterubix.com

2

Sounds like excellent therapy, I'm sure a lot of your students appreciate the familiar face of a clown which traditionally is none threatening! I found your reference to their presence bringing hope to wartorn countries reassuring....despite Stephen King turning everything upside down with his IT novel!

1

Thank you Aurthur.
Ken

2

Thanks Kenny!
Kind regards
~Arthur

2

Thank you Aurthur.
Ken

2

Good post. Yes, words can destroy a lot of people. Awesome video. Thanks for the link. For the rest reading this --- if you don't have time for the full video at least watch the last 7 minutes.

2

Great that you found the video so powerful albeit a bit long!
Kind regards
~Arthur

2

Hi WillingToTry, your post is great and the video superb. Thanks for sharing.

2

Thank you Hector,
Kind regards
~Arthur

2

See more comments

Join FREE & Launch Your Business!

Exclusive Bonus - Offer Ends at Midnight Today

00

Hours

:

00

Minutes

:

00

Seconds

2,000 AI Credits Worth $10 USD

Build a Logo + Website That Attracts Customers

400 Credits

Discover Hot Niches with AI Market Research

100 Credits

Create SEO Content That Ranks & Converts

800 Credits

Find Affiliate Offers Up to $500/Sale

10 Credits

Access a Community of 2.9M+ Members

By continuing, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
No credit card required

2.9M+

Members

190+

Countries Served

20+

Years Online

50K+

Success Stories

The world's most successful affiliate marketing training platform. Join 2.9M+ entrepreneurs building their online business with expert training, tools, and support.

© 2005-2025 Wealthy Affiliate
All rights reserved worldwide.

🔒 Trusted by Millions Worldwide

Since 2005, Wealthy Affiliate has been the go-to platform for entrepreneurs looking to build successful online businesses. With industry-leading security, 99.9% uptime, and a proven track record of success, you're in safe hands.