Work with what you have, start adding content on a regular basis and you'll see your rankings rise. No point in starting over.

I agree with Marion keep it and update it

I'd stick to the one you already have and just keep adding new content. Google will see the new content and your sitemap.xml will link to the old content and refresh the old posts and pages. Use Jaaxy or the WA free Keyword Tool to choose titles for your new posts. Good luck. ~Marion

I would say keep your existing and work on that again. Only if you are fully satisfied with your domainname, and the niche, but this is something you said already...

A new website starts fresh, it can also be done with the help of the training here in WA, but as I said: in my opinion, there is no need for changing anything.

The question is, where you host your website.
Since we have wordpress hosting included here in WA, I would choose to go with the included hosting here, rather than paying some hosting service anywhere else... In that case I would start fresh here with WA's service.

This is only my personal opinion. I am interested how other people see that ;o)

Cheers, Kay

Renee, I just left you a comment on your website.

fyi, You have two spelling errors you need to correct.

1) You have Pintrest and it should be Pinterest
2) You have Linkin and it should be LinkedIn

Great post!

Hi. I have checked out your website and you do have good ideas. See I have sent a link to an article on my website about publishing eBooks. Let me know if the tips are meaningful. All the best to you!
http://wealthyaim.com/earning-from-e-book-publishing

HI you've got an nice site on social media. If you truly believe it's something that no one else has written about, then you can sell it at a reasonable price, then offer something else for free as a bonus, being new to the business. Just make sure you're adding more content to you website to add more followers/visitors.