Evergreen Content: Why “Set and Forget” Is a Myth (My Update Routine)

Evergreen posts might sound like a blogger’s retirement plan, but even your “forever” content needs a little TLC if you want it to stay useful, visible, and relevant. Here’s why, and exactly how I keep mine growing.

Why Even the Best Evergreen Posts Go Stale

Evergreen content sounds like the dream gig: you publish once, relax, and watch the clicks come in forever. When I first started blogging, I totally bought into this idea. I’d hit publish and feel like I’d just invested in something futureproof. But over time, I learned that even “timeless” posts can get pretty scruffy if you never look back at them.

One day, you land on an old post that was ranking like a champ. Now, it’s buried. Maybe a stat looks ancient, a link goes nowhere, or your advice is embarrassingly out of date. Trust me, evergreen doesn’t really mean “done forever.”

The Wake-Up Call: When My “Forever” Post Flopped

Not every evergreen post is built the same way. A list of basic SEO tools or a guide to cleaning stainless steel might last a while, but anything tied to statistics, platform updates, or even trends like “the best free apps” has an expiration date. I’ve seen my own “timeless” content go stale just because Google changed something or a tool I recommended disappeared.

Some posts that I thought would bring steady traffic for years barely made it through six months before feeling dated. Even obvious evergreens, like baking recipes or how-to guides, benefit from small tweaks as readers change or as new info pops up.

The first time I really noticed a problem, I was scrolling through my analytics, trying to figure out why one of my top posts had tanked. It turns out that half the outbound links were broken, and the quote from a 2018 report made me cringe. That was a wake-up call.

Early on, my strategy was basically: hit publish, move on, and let Google do its thing. That only worked until an old tutorial of mine started suggesting downloads from sources that didn’t even exist anymore. I learned pretty fast that leaving content alone is a recipe for embarrassing surprises and lost traffic.

Sometimes revisiting an old post is like pulling on a jacket you haven’t worn in a year, sometimes you find a $20 bill, but more often, it’s just an outdated receipt and a note to yourself you can’t decipher.

How I Keep Evergreen Content Fresh: My Update Routine

How Often I Revisit Old Posts

I try to check my main evergreen posts every three to six months, and sometimes even sooner if a trend in my niche moves quickly. I also prefer to do rolling updates whenever I spot something weird or if readers start asking questions that reveal holes or mistakes in the old post.

What Actually Triggers an Update

There are a few things that get me to jump in and update:

• A sudden drop in traffic, with Google Search Console usually giving me a heads up
• Industry news or big updates in a tool, platform, or process I cover
• Random scrolls where I cringe at my own outdated advice
• Reader comments pointing out something that's not working or needs more details

My Personal Update Checklist

• Links: I click every external and internal link in the post. If something is dead or irrelevant, it goes.
• Stats: Outdated numbers get swapped for the latest I can track down, usually with a new link to a trusted source.
• Images: If a screenshot or image looks old or the platform UI has changed, I update it so it matches what readers see now.
• SEO: While I'm in there, I check if the keywords are still a good fit, tweak meta descriptions, and see if the competition has changed.
• Relevance & Accuracy: I redo examples if they no longer apply, fix anything that's confused readers, and add new hacks or insights I’ve learned since the first publish.

Updates, Surprises, and the Occasional Cringe

I’ve updated posts and seen new traffic spikes from Google, especially when a refresh matches up with a trending search or a new product launch. One time, I swapped in a new step-by-step tutorial, and my page bounced right back to page one after slipping for months. There’s nothing like seeing the power of an update in your stats.

Of course, I’ve also cringed at my old advice, like recommending a workflow tool that completely shut down last year. Once, a reader even pointed out that my "quick fix" tip for a tech issue was now making things worse, not better. Those comments aren’t fun, but they've kept me on my toes.

And let’s be honest, sometimes digging into an old post is a surprise in itself: maybe you discover a gem, or maybe it’s just digital dust and cobwebs. Either way, it’s never boring.

Sometimes updates don’t move the needle right away, and that’s okay. Other times, an edit brings in more comments, saves someone a headache, or just helps my post compete with hungry new bloggers in the same keyword space. Either way, it’s always worth it for me to check in and polish things up.

Tools and Tricks That Make Updates Easy

I use a few tricks to save time and keep my update routine running smoothly:

• Google Search Console: I check performance for posts that suddenly dip or for changes in top search terms.
• Broken Link Checker plugins: These run in the background and alert me when something’s busted.
• Editorial calendar or reminders: I set quarterly reminders for my big evergreen guides and jot quick notes in my planner if someone points out a problem.
• Spreadsheets: I track URLs, last update dates, and any major tweaks. This makes the process easier than trying to check my entire site all at once.

Final Take: Freshness Beats “Set and Forget”— Always

Freshness is just as important as quality if you want your evergreen content to keep doing its job. My old "set and forget" approach left a trail of wilted guides and lost traffic, so now, regular updates are nonnegotiable for me. Even a quick ten-minute sweep can make a difference.

If you’ve got some posts you haven’t checked in a while, it’s definitely worth looking them over. How often do you update your own old posts? Got a favorite update tool or routine? Share your process, or feel free to ask anything, in the comments!