When using two AI's - Here's some information - straight from the AI

I loved Mel's post on getting two AI' to talk. I couldn't wait to learn about this, so I, of course, asked ChatGPT. Here's what I learned:

Described Mel's post and asked Chat the following questions

ME: I just read that another member who has been using AI to help with his publishing business has managed to have 2 AI's (chatGPT and Claude) talk with each other and is going to explore using both to help him. This is fascinating. Tell me how can this work? What are the issues if any? and what are the advantages?

AI: As for using ChatGPT and Claude together, that's becoming increasingly common among power users, authors, programmers, researchers, and marketers.

Think of it like having two very intelligent consultants sitting at a table.

How People Make Two AIs "Talk"

The simplest method is surprisingly low-tech.

1. Ask ChatGPT a question.
2. Copy the answer.
3. Paste it into Claude and ask for feedback, improvements, or criticism.
4. Take Claude's response back to ChatGPT.
5. Continue the conversation.

Some people automate the process using software, APIs, or agent frameworks, but manual copy-and-paste works perfectly well.

For example:

You ask ChatGPT:

Create a marketing plan for my tea blog.

Then you ask Claude:

Here is ChatGPT's plan. What weaknesses do you see?

Claude critiques it.

Then you return to ChatGPT:

Claude identified these weaknesses. How would you address them?

The result is often better than relying on either AI alone.

Advantages

1. Different Strengths

Many users find:

• ChatGPT tends to be very creative, conversational, and versatile.
• Claude tends to be excellent at long-form analysis, editing, and spotting logical gaps.

Neither is always better.

They're simply different.

It's similar to asking two experienced editors to review the same manuscript.

2. Reduced Blind Spots

Every AI has limitations.

If one AI makes a mistake, the other may catch it.

For example:

• Factual errors
• Weak reasoning
• Missing considerations
• Poor organization

This is especially valuable when:

• Writing books
• Creating courses
• Building websites
• Developing business plans

3. Better Brainstorming

One AI may generate ideas that the other expands upon.

You can create a cycle:

ChatGPT → Claude → ChatGPT → Claude

The ideas often become more refined with each round.

4. Improved Editing

Authors are doing this already.

A workflow might look like:

• ChatGPT writes a chapter draft.
• Claude edits for clarity and flow.
• ChatGPT rewrites sections.
• Claude performs a final review.

The end result can be quite polished.

Potential Problems

1. The "Echo Chamber" Effect

This is the biggest issue.

If you ask:

Is this a great idea?

Both AIs may tend toward agreement.

You don't necessarily get objective truth.

You get two systems trying to be helpful.

That's why it's often better to ask:

What are the weaknesses?

What would a critic say?

What could go wrong?

2. AI Can Reinforce AI Mistakes

If ChatGPT makes an incorrect assumption and Claude accepts it, the mistake can snowball.

Two AIs agreeing does not guarantee correctness.

Humans still need to verify important facts.

3. Cost and Complexity

Managing multiple AI systems:

• Takes more time
• Costs more money
• Creates more information to review

Sometimes one AI is sufficient.

4. Over-Optimization

I've seen examples where people keep passing content back and forth until all the personality disappears.

The writing becomes technically perfect but bland.

For blogging, especially your Shirley-style writing, maintaining your own voice is important.

Where This Could Help You

Knowing the projects you work on, I think a dual-AI workflow could be particularly useful for:

Your Books

ChatGPT:

• Generate ideas
• Create outlines
• Draft chapters

Claude:

• Review consistency
• Check flow
• Suggest improvements

Your Blog Posts

ChatGPT:

• Create first draft

Claude:

• Identify weak sections
• Suggest missing topics

You:

• Add personal stories and experience

Your Product Descriptions

ChatGPT:

• Draft description

Claude:

• Improve readability
• Remove repetition

Your Bella Vista Site

ChatGPT:

• Create article drafts

Claude:

• Review for local-interest appeal
• Improve structure

What I find most fascinating isn't that two AIs can talk to each other.

It's that they can act as a kind of "thinking team."

Years ago, a writer might have needed:

• A research assistant
• An editor
• A proofreader
• A brainstorming partner

Now a single person can fill many of those roles with AI assistance.

The important part is that the human remains the decision-maker.

In your case, the most valuable piece is still something neither AI has: your life experience. Neither ChatGPT nor Claude spent 33 years at the FDA, ran a photography business, built websites for local clients, hosted tea parties, or lives in Bella Vista. That's the perspective that turns AI-generated content into something readers actually connect with.

***************************

Me: I found this very interesting personally and can see where Mel is having success with his writing and publishing. I wish I was more interested in writing and publishing myself, but everyone has their own "things". I don't currently have an account with Claude myself, Maybe I'll explore that. But I thought I'd share this information with other members. Nice to be aware of how "power users" are using this and that it has potential for each of us also. - Shirley

Additional reading material:

https://www.informationweek.com/machine-learning-ai/why-using-multiple-ais-is-trending-now

https://multiple.chat/

https://www.forbes.com/sites/lanceeliot/2025/02/04/unraveling-the-curious-mystery-of-two-different-ai-models-suddenly-forming-a-new-language-of-their-very-own/ (different use)

https://www.usecouncil.app/how-to/use-multiple-ais-together

https://www.chataiduo.com/ (a dual system offer)

https://seldaseyfi.substack.com/p/the-dirty-little-insider-secret-about-using-multiple-ais (do you want to become an air traffic controller?)

https://www.reddit.com/r/ArtificialInteligence/comments/1ccvar7/i_created_an_app_where_ais_can_speak_with_each/ (some is going to make lots of money off this with an app)