Why doesn't my reply go with the commenters?
Okay, I am having the hardest time trying to find a solution to my comments and replies in WordPress.
Can someone tell me if it's in the WP settings somewhere, my theme, or plugin that is causing the replies not to go with the comments?
Site support suggested deactivating each plugin to see who's the culprit.
I have the same plugin as my other site and they are not causing any issues.
Thank you everyone I have found the culprit! Only took 4 weeks!
It was a WordPress setting. Make sure, in your other comment setting, enable thread (nested) comments_levels deep is turn on or check the box next to it.
Settings > discussion > other comment settings > enable thread (nested) comments_levels deep
It's recommended to go 3 levels deep!
Woohoo! Thank goodness.